1. Electricity and investments – the current situation
Figure 2: Top 10 countries – electricity generation in 2022
(1) Electricity production share of respective country; (2) CAGR – compound annual growth rate 2012-2022 in %; (3) Includes other renewables& other.
Source: Schernikau Research and Analysis based on Energy Institute 2023
Fossil fuels – in order of importanceoil, coal, and gas make up ~80% of global primary energy (“PE”) production, totaling ~170.000 TWh or ~600 EJ. Despite Covid-19, geopolitical turmoil, and significant wind and solar capacity additions, it is estimated that the percentage will not change in 2023 or 2024; quite to the contrary, coal is making a comeback (IEA 2022). Coal and gas made up ~60% of global gross electricity production, totaling ~29.200 TWh in 2022. Three countries alone, China, the USA, and India, make up ~50% of global electricity consumption (Figure 2). It is important to note that global electricity production consumes up to ~40% of primary energy, with transportation, heating, and industry accounting for the remaining ~60% (Figure 3 andFigure 35, p104).
Realistic primary energy growth of ~50% until 2050 is driven by ~25% population growth and ~20% average per capita energy demand growth. This contrasts with IRENA’s, McKinsey’s, and the IEA’s “Net-Zero” pathways, which often assume much less growth and either flat or even a ~10% drop in primary energy. McKinsey 2022b assumes a 14% rise until 2035 and thereafter flat primary energy consumption until 2050. IEA Net-Zero 2021 assumes a 10% drop in primary energy consumption demand as early as 2030. The “primary energy” measure and the misconception of falling primary energy with solar and wind’s increased penetration is discussed inChapter 2.7.
Figure 3: Overview of global primary energy and electricity in 2022
(1) Only the portion of Industry/Transport/Building that is not included under electricity; (2) assumed worldwide net efficiency of ~33% for nuclear, ~37% for coal, ~42% for gas. With an assumed avg. ~40% efficiency => 2~29.000 TWh becomes ~72.000 TWh or roughly 40% of ~170.000 TWh.
Source: Schernikau Research and Analysis based on Energy Institute 2023 and IEA Statistics 2023
Current energy policy focuses on the electrification of energy, thus significantly increasing electricity’s share of primary energy by increasing the use of electricity for transportation (see EVs), heating (see heat pumps), and industry (see DRI, direct reduced iron, producing steel using hydrogen). Therefore, this book focuses on electricity. For a more comprehensive discussion on transportation, we recommend Kiefer’s 2013Twenty-First Century Snake Oil, which includes details on hydrocarbons and biofuels for transportation that are not covered herein in detail.
Despite the trillions of US dollars spent globally on the “energy transition” (Figure 4), the proportion of fossil fuels as part of total energy supply has been essentially constant at around 80% since the 1970s, when gross energy consumption was less than half as high (WEF 2020). Also in Europe, fossil fuels’ share is still above 70%, in Germany ~80%. Kober et al. 2020 among others, confirm that total primary energy consumption more than doubled in the 40 years between 1978 to 2018. At the same time, the energy intensity of GDP improved by a little less than 1%, confirming the Jevon’s Paradox thatenergy efficiency improvements are in principle offset by higher energy demand (Polimeni et al. 2015).
Figure 4: Investments in coal are one third of wind/solar, while coal provides ~3x more electricity
Note: Investments are considering investments in fuels and power.
Source: Schernikau Research and Analysis based on IEA WEI 2023, Energy Institute 2023 and BNEF 2023
Variable “renewables”1 in the form of wind and solar accounted for ~5%