: Barbara Maier, Warren A. Shibles
: The Philosophy and Practice of Medicine and Bioethics A Naturalistic-Humanistic Approach
: Springer-Verlag
: 9789048188673
: 1
: CHF 190.00
:
: Allgemeines
: English
: 543
: Wasserzeichen/DRM
: PC/MAC/eReader/Tablet
: PDF
This book challenges the unchallenged methods in medicine, such as 'evidence-based medicine,' which claim to be, but often are not, scientific. It completes medical care by adding the comprehensive humanistic perspectives and philosophy of medicine. No specific or absolute recommendations are given regarding medical treatment, moral approaches, or legal advice. Given rather is discussion about each issue involved and the strongest arguments indicated. Each argument is subject to further critical analysis. This is the same position as with any philosophical, medical or scientific view. The argument that decision-making in medicine is inadequate unless grounded on a philosophy of medicine is not meant to include all of philosophy and every philosopher. On the contrary, it includes only sound, practical and humanistic philosophy and philosophers who are creative and critical thinkers and who have concerned themselves with the topics relevant to medicine. These would be those philosophers who engage in practical philosophy, such as the pragmatists, humanists, naturalists, and ordinary-language philosophers. A new definition of our own philosophy of life emerges and it is necessary to have one. Good lifestyle no longer means just abstaining from cigarettes, alcohol and getting exercise. It also means living a holistic life, which includes all of one's thinking, personality and actions. This book also includes new ways of thinking. In this regard the 'Metaphorical Method' is explained, used, and exemplified in depth, for example in the chapters on care, egoism and altruism, letting die, etc.

Warren Shibles was a Senior philosophy professor at the University of Wisconsin at Whitewater, Wisconsin and also taught courses at Tübingen, Germany. He has published 27 books, and over 180 professional journal articles.He also was a researcher in phonetics. He died in July 2007. Barbara Maier is a Senior physician, gynaecologist and obstetrician at the Women`s Hospital in Salzburg and head of the Department of Gynaecological Endocrinology and Assisted Reproduction at the University Clinic of Gynaecology and Obstetrics in Salzburg, Austria. She has been teaching ethics in medicine at the Institute for Ethics and Law at the University of Vienna since 1993. She has a Ph.D. in Philosophy, and M.D from the University of Vienna.
Contents7
The Rationale Behind the Book18
About the Authors22
1 Metaphor in Medicine: The Metaphorical Method23
1.1 Introduction23
1.2 Types of Metaphor26
1.2.1 Substitution26
1.2.2 Juxtaposition26
1.2.3 Analogy, Simile, or Comparison26
1.2.4 Symbolism26
1.2.5 Metonymy26
1.2.6 Synecdoche27
1.2.7 Synesthesia27
1.2.8 Reversal27
1.2.9 Personification27
1.2.10 Oxymora or Combination of Opposites28
1.2.11 Deviation28
1.2.12 Metaphor-to-Myth Fallacy28
1.3 Metaphorical Methods Should be Considered for Analysis of and Writing Research Papers29
1.4 Case Example: A Healthcare Worker (H) Patient (P) Metaphoric: H/P Modeling in Medicine33
1.5 H/P Models34
1.5.1 H = P34
1.5.2 H versus P34
1.5.3 Not H and not P34
1.5.4 H or P35
1.5.5 H and P35
1.5.6 H not P35
1.5.7 P not H35
1.5.8 H (verb) P35
1.5.9 P (verb) H35
1.5.10 H = P35
1.5.11 H ? P35
References36
2 Definition37
2.1 Where Does It Come from that We Think We Need to Define?37
2.2 Distinction Between Types of Definition40
References43
3 Decision-Making: Fallacies and Other Mistakes45
3.1 Conditions of Decision-Making45
3.2 Frequent Causes of Irrational Medical Thinking and Decision-Making46
3.3 Five Levels of Decision-Making in Medicine50
3.4 Fallacies in Decision-Making51
3.5 Mistakes56
3.5.1 What are Mistakes?56
3.5.2 What are Indications of Errors?57
3.5.3 Indications that Mistakes are Often Preventable Ones58
3.5.4 What are the Reasons for the Mistakes?59
3.5.4.1 Questionable Medical Treatments59
3.5.4.2 Error is Necessary59
3.5.4.3 Uncritical Thinking (Speaking)59
3.5.4.4 Medical Knowledge Is Lacking59
3.5.4.5 System as a Cause of Error59
3.5.4.6 Some Mistakes Are Not Mistakes60
3.5.4.7 Guidelines Are Not Followed60
3.5.4.8 Self-Caused Mistakes60
3.5.4.9 Patient Errors60
3.5.4.10 Lack of Sufficient Attention60
3.5.4.11 Misdiagnosis60
3.5.4.12 Overwork61
3.5.4.13 Limitations of Knowledge in Medicine61
3.5.4.14 Unfair Medical Threats of Malpractice Suits Threaten Physicians61
3.5.4.15 Unfair Blame61
3.5.4.16 Protocols of Good Management Are Violated62
3.5.4.17 Unfairness of the Law62
3.5.4.18 Negative Emotions63
3.5.5 Case Example: Misleading Diagnosis63
3.5.6 Personal Experiences: Mistakes64
References65
4 Analysis of Causation in Medicine67
4.1 Decision-Making and Cause68
4.2 Synonyms of Cause70
4.3 Antonyms for Cause71
4.4 Metaphorical Models for Cause71
4.5 Substitutions for Cause71
4.6 Temporal Factors in Causality71
4.7 Types of Causality72
4.8 Summary84
References85
5 Ethics and Non-ethics87
5.1 Introduction87
5.2 A Naturalistic Theory of Ethics91
5.3 What Is Ethics in Actual Usage?94
5.4 Ethics and Morals: An Unethical Society102
5.5 Value Contradictions105
5.6 Examples of Contradictions106
5.7 On Being Non-ethical and Anti-Inquiry109
5.8 Brief Conclusion111
5.9 An Ethics Text for British Medical Schools112
5.10 Case Example: Medicine and Dysfunctional Culture (Made Available by Dr Wolf Michael Luetje, Head of the Womens Hospital Viersee in Germany)113
5.11 Case Example: Military Medical Service as Contradictory to Medical Practice114
5.12 Insensitivity to Killing: The Failure to be Embarrassed117
5.13 Case Example: On Sensitivity119
5.14 Case Example: Tsunami Disaster and Cultural Irresponsibility120
5.15 Case Example: Culture and Family as Anti-Medicine: Female Circumcision122
References125
6 Medicotheology and Biotheology133
6.1 Introduction: How Many People Have Religious Beliefs?133
6.2 The Influence of Religion on Bioethics and Medicine134
6.3 Church Opposition to Medicine137
6.4 Should Medicine Be Based on Supernaturalism?139
6.5 Science and Metaphysical Causes?139
6.6 Case Example: Religion and Autonomy140
6.7 Religion Versus Medicine: A Common Ground?141
6.8 Religion as Ethics142
6.9 Ethics Committees143
6.10 Humanism Versus Religion144
6.11 Absolute Religious Ethics Versus Consequentialism145
6.12 Case Example: Deprogramming Religion in Medicine145
6.13 Case Example: A Real Woman146
6.14 The Person as a Soul147
6.15 Sanctity-of-Life (Human)147
6.16 General Observations Regarding the Value of Human Life148
6.17 Contradictions Regarding the Sanctity-of-Life Doctrine149
6.18 Selected Arguments from the Philosophy of Religion150
6.19 Prayer as Medical Treatment151
References154
7 Emotion In Medicine158
7.1 Introduction158
7.2 Case Example: Non-mental Associations Provide Complexity to