: Girum G. Alemu
: Managing Risk and Securing Livelihood The Karrayu Pastoralists, their Environment and the Ethiopian State
: Franz Steiner Verlag
: 9783515114059
: Erdkundliches Wissen
: 1
: CHF 41.80
:
: Geografie
: English
: 187
: Wasserzeichen/DRM
: PC/MAC/eReader/Tablet
: PDF

The hegemonic perspective on adaptation solely focuses on climate stimuli as the driving force behind people's adaptation. Such a perspective underestimates the role played by historical trajectories of political and social forces of change in shaping current adaptation practices. In doing so, it also separates the environment from processes of social change. This work challenges this dominant view by arguing that adaptation practices pursued by pastoral communities need to be seen at the intersection of state-environment-pastoralist -interactions. In other words, the understanding of pastoralists' risk management and livelihood practices requires a perspective that situates local actors into their broader socio-political and environmental contexts. By using a political ecology approach that emphasizes on the agency of pastoral actors, this work demonstrates how the Karrayyu pastoral groups of upper Awash valley develop and use various risk management and livelihood practices under the influence of both socio-political and ecological sources of change.



Girum G. Alemu currently works as research associate at the Institute for Advanced Sustainability Studies (IASS) in Potsdam. He is interested in three broader but interrelated research topics: Political ecology, environment and development policy and livelihood security. His research interest mainly focuses on the interaction between broader scale political economy and local human-environment interactions and the implications of these interactions on livelihoods security.
TABLE OF CONTENTS6
LIST OF FIGURES10
LIST OF TABLES11
LIST OF PHOTOS12
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS13
GLOSSARY15
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS18
ABSTRACT20
ZUSAMMENFASSUNG22
1. INTRODUCTION24
1.1 THE PROBLEMATICS OF THE HEGEMONIC ADAPTATION PERSPECTIVE24
1.2 APOLITICAL ADAPTATION AND PASTORALISTS’ DEVELOPMENT26
1.3 APPROACHING THE ‘LOCAL CONTEXTS’ FROM A POLITICAL ECOLOGY PERSPECTIVE29
1.4 POINT OF DEPARTURE: RISK, RESOURCES AND RELATIONAL MODES31
1.5 ORGANIZATION OF THE BOOK34
2. ADAPTATION, VULNERABILITY AND LOCAL AGENCY: THEORETICAL AND CONCEPTUAL REFLECTIONS36
2.1 INTRODUCTION36
2.2 PUTTING THE CONCEPT OF ADAPTATION IN PERSPECTIVE36
2.3 THE CONVENTIONAL APPROACH TO ADAPTATION37
2.4 THE INADEQUACY OF THE CONVENTIONAL APPROACH39
2.5 THE CONCEPT OF VULNERABILITY IN ADAPTATION RESEARCH40
2.6 POLITICAL ECOLOGY AND THE VULNERABILITY PARADIGM46
2.7 LOCATING ACTORS IN POLITICAL ECOLOGY48
2.8 SUMMARY51
3. RESEARCHING WITH THE LOCALS: METHODOLOGICAL REFLECTIONS52
3.1 INTRODUCTION52
3.2 UPPER AWASH VALLEY, FENTALLE WOREDA: DESCRIPTIONS53
3.3 METHODOLOGICAL STANCES: QUALITATIVE APPROACH IN GEOGRAPHY57
3.4 THE RESEARCH PROCESS: PRELIMINARY VISITS AND INITIAL ACQUAINTANCE59
3.5 MIXING VARIOUS INTERVIEW TECHNIQUES64
3.6 FIELD NOTES AND PARTICIPANT OBSERVATION67
3.7 DOCUMENT ANALYSIS AND SECONDARY INFORMATION68
3.8 ANALYSIS AND WRITE UP68
3.9 ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS69
4. LIVELIHOOD INSECURITY IN CONTEXT: HISTORICAL TRAJECTORIES71
4.1 INTRODUCTION71
4.2 STATE-PASTORALISTS RELATIONS: ‘DEVELOPMENT’ AND THE PERILS OF PLANNING72
4.3 ENVIRONMENTAL SOURCES OF LIVELIHOOD RISK80
4.4 THE POST-1991 STATE IN PASTORAL SPACES: A LIABILITY OR AN ASSET?88
4.5 IN-MIGRATION AND INCREASED POPULATION PRESSURE95
4.6 SUMMARY: MULTIPLE SOURCES OF LIVELIHOOD INSECURITY98
5. ENVIRONMENTAL TRANSFORMATION AND LIVESTOCKBASED LIVELIHOOD PRACTICES101
5.1 INTRODUCTION101
5.2 ENVIRONMENTAL TRANSFORMATION AND SOCIAL DISORGANIZATION101
5.3 PASTORALISTS’ AGENCY AND RESPONSE TO CHANGE110
5.4 CONTEXTS INFLUENCING PASTORAL MOBILITY DECISIONS115
5.5 REORGANIZATION: CAMEL-BASED LIVELIHOOD PRACTICES118
5.6 SURVIVING ON CAMELS: RISK MANAGEMENT AND LIVELIHOOD PRACTICES119
5.7 SUMMARY128
6. LIVING THE TRANSFORMATION: THE MOVE TOWARDS AGRO-PASTORALISM129
6.1 INTRODUCTION129
6.2 CULTIVATION AS RISK MANAGEMENT AND LIVELIHOOD PRACTICE129
6.3 SIGNIFICANT ASPECTS INFLUENCING DECISIONS TO CULTIVATE131
6.4 BRINGING NEW PRINCIPLES IN: FENCING COMMUNAL PASTURE142
6.5 EMERGENCE OF NEW ARRANGEMENTS143
6.6 SOME CONSTRAINTS TO CULTIVATION AS A CONTEMPORARY STRATEGY151
6.7 NON-PASTORAL AND NON-AGRICULTURAL ACTIVITIES153
6.8 SUMMARY157
7. CONTEXTUALIZED ADAPTATION: HEGEMONIC PERSPECTIVES AND LOCAL RESPONSES159
7.1 INTRODUCTION159
7.2 THE POLITICS OF ADAPTATION: TOP-DOWN APPROACHES TO DEVELOPMENT160
7.3 SITUATED AND LOCAL-LEVEL ADAPTATION PRACTICES162
7.4 SUMMARY168
8. CONCLUSIONS169
8.1 STARTING-POINT VULNERABILITY: THE POLITICAL ECOLOGY OF LOCAL ADAPTATION169
8.2 LOCATING AGENCY IN POLITICAL ECOLOGY171
8.3 LOCALIZING THE INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVE ON ADAPTATION TO CLIMATE CHANGE173
8.4 BACK TO THE RESEARCH QUESTIONS174
8.5 IMPLICATIONS FOR POLICY AND DIRECTIONS FOR FUTURE RESEARCH176
9. LIST OF REFERENCES180