: Stefanie Haustein
: Multidimensional Journal Evaluation Analyzing Scientific Periodicals beyond the Impact Factor
: De Gruyter Saur
: 9783110255553
: Knowledge and InformationISSN
: 1
: CHF 120.40
:
: Buchhandel, Bibliothekswesen
: English
: 416
: Wasserzeichen/DRM
: PC/MAC/eReader/Tablet
: PDF
< >Scientific communication depends primarily on publishing in journals. The most important indicator to determine the influence of a journal is the Impact Factor. Since this factor only measures the average number of citations per article in a certain time window, it can be argued that it does not reflect the actual value of a periodical. This book defines five dimensions, which build a framework for a multidimensional method of journal evaluation. The author is winner of the Eugene Garfield Doctoral Dissertation Scholarship 2011.



< >Stefanie Haustein, Forschungszentrum Jülich and Heinrich-Heine-Universitä t Düsseldorf

Contents6
Chapter 1 Introduction10
1.1 The Scholarly Journal13
1.1.1 Definitions13
1.1.2 Emergence and Development14
1.2 Application and Developments of Journal Evaluation16
1.3 Multidimensional Journal Evaluation21
1.3.1 Inability of a Single Metric21
1.3.2 Multidimensionality22
1.4 Case Study26
References28
Chapter 2 Journal Output32
2.1 Output Indicators34
2.1.1 Number of Issues and Documents34
2.1.2 Document Length37
2.1.3 Document Titles41
2.1.4 Document Types41
2.1.5 References44
2.1.6 Publishing Language54
2.2 Producers of Output57
2.2.1 Authors58
2.2.2 Institutions70
2.2.3 Countries72
Summary77
References79
Chapter 3 Journal Content86
3.1 Digression: Indexing Methods87
3.1.1 Classification Systems and Thesauri89
3.1.2 Human vs. Automatic Indexing92
3.1.3 Author Keywords94
3.1.4 Citation Indexing95
3.1.5 Key Words Plus99
3.1.6 Social Tagging100
3.2 Level of Analysis103
3.2.1 Journal Level103
3.2.2 Article Level113
3.3 Content Trend Analysis147
3.4 Content Similarity Analysis152
3.4.1 Bibliographic Coupling and Co-Citations152
3.4.2 Co-word Analysis153
3.4.3 Co-occurrence of Users and Tags156
Summary160
References162
Chapter 4 Journal Perception and Usage172
4.1 Reader Surveys174
4.1.1 Journal Rankings175
4.1.2 Demographic Readership Analysis177
4.2 Download Data178
4.2.1 Local Usage Data180
4.2.2 Global Usage Data193
4.2.3 Download-based Usage Indicators201
4.3 Usage Data from Social Bookmarking207
4.3.1 Data Collection208
4.3.2 Bookmarking Indicators217
4.3.3 Comparison with Citation Indicators220
Summary221
References224
Chapter 5 Journal Citations232
5.1 Basic Indicators238
5.1.1 Mean Citation Rates241
5.1.2 Distribution-based Indicators253
5.1.3 H-index259
5.1.4 Time-based Indicators262
5.1.5 Citing Sources268
5.2 Weighted Indicators272
5.2.1 Influence Weight and Influence per Publication273
5.2.2 Eigenfactor and Article Influence Score274
5.2.3 SCImago Journal Rank278
5.3 Normalized Indicators283
5.3.1 Cited-side Normalization284
5.3.2 Citing-side Normalization288
Summary298
References300
Chapter 6 Journal Management310
6.1 General Journal Characteristics310
6.1.1 Age and Publication History311
6.1.2 Publisher Affiliation315
6.1.3 Scope316
6.2 Composition of the Editorial Board319
6.2.1 Size320
6.2.2 Internationally322
6.3 From Submission to Publication326
6.3.1 Review Process328
6.3.2 Publication Delay333
6.3.3 Rejection Rate338
6.3.4 Correction Rate345
6.4 The Publishing Market346
6.4.1 Production Costs348
6.4.2 Financial Models349
6.4.3 Journal Prices356
Summary365
References367
Chapter 7 Conclusions and Outlook376
7.1 The Author’s Perspective378
7.2 The Reader’s Perspective380
7.3 The Librarian’s Perspective385
7.4 The Editor’s and Publisher’s Perspectives387
7.5 Outlook389
References391
List of Abbreviations392
List of Figures396
List of Tables400
Author Index402
Subject Index412