: Frank T. Manheim
: The Conflict Over Environmental Regulation in the United States Origins, Outcomes, and Comparisons With the EU and Other Regions
: Springer-Verlag
: 9780387758770
: 1
: CHF 47.50
:
: Volkswirtschaft
: English
: 318
: Wasserzeichen/DRM
: PC/MAC/eReader/Tablet
: PDF
in Congress - are not considered, they may affect future energy programs just as they have past programs. Finally, potentially ruinously costly increases in energy imports force attention to the problem of how major public policy plans have been and are prepared in the United States. A witches' brew of some 500 energy bills proposed in the 110th C ongress in the House and Senate is now being stirred up. This 'inspirational' approach to public policymaking bears little resemblance to the thoughtful way critical policies have been developed in the EU. A change of the way major national planning is undertaken may do more than anything else to bring facts and reality into play, reduce hostilities, open up cooperation, new resources, technologies, creative energies, and productivity toward energy policy transitions. Chapter 6 Foreign Experience 6. 1 The European Union and Other Nations Take the Lead 'The EU has pioneered a new form of post-national government, in which nation-states pool some of their sovereignty for the common good. Many of its admirers see this as a useful potential model for Southeast Asia, the Indian subcontinent, China-Taiwan, Latin America, parts of Africa and so on. The EU takes some issues, like human rights, global warming and the fostering of an international system of justice, with admirable seriousness . . . . . . Considering the kind of Europe it replaced, the EU has been an almost miraculous success (Walker, 2007).

Frank T. Manheim is an affiliate professor in the School of Public Policy, George Mason University. In course of more than 30 years as a federal government ocean and earth scientist he served on numerous interagency and scientific advisory panels including the National Academy of Science--National Research Council, National Science Foundation, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Bureau of Land Management and Minerals Management Service, and industry associations. Manheim has cooperated with European, Russian, and Japanese scientists and agencies and is a recipient of the Swedish Academy of Science Pettersson Medal for Excellence in Ocean Research. He is an author of 190 published articles and has edited or co-edited five books.
Prologue6
Acknowledgments9
Contents10
Part I The Story16
Our Current Conflict17
1.1 Politics in America17
1.2 Environmentalists Versus Industry: A Collision Between Two Post- World War II Movements20
1.3 Battles over Offshore Oil and ANWR23
1.4 Isolation of Information Systems Among Environmental Activists, Academic Analysts, and Producers25
1.4.1 Environmentalist Communication25
1.4.2 Industry Communication26
1.4.3 Industry Lobbying27
1.4.4 Academic Publication – The Separation of Theory from Practice28
1.4.5 Popular Media, Blogs, and Government Publications28
1.4.6 The Isolation of Information Systems Is Revealed in the US Global Climate Change Debate29
1.4.7 Militancy of US Environmental Organizations30
Tracing the Roots of the Conflict34
2.1 Engineers and Pre-World War II America34
2.2 1950s–1960s: Environmental and Other Stresses Begin to Erode the Boom36
2.3 A New Academic Paradigm37
2.3.1 The Vision and the Reality39
2.3.2 Diversion of US Scientific and Technical Talent?43
2.4 The Modern Offshore Oil Industry44
2.4.1 Regulatory Developments46
2.5 The Turbulent 1960s: Increasing Pollution, Environmental Problems, the Counterculture, and a Preoccupied Administration47
2.5.1 Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring and Rise of a New Environmental Movement49
2.6 Remedial Action Falters4951
2.6.1 The Stratton Commission Report and President Richard Nixon52
2.6.2 Contending Philosophies for Environmental Management53
2.7 The Collision: The Santa Barbara Oil Spill of 196955
2.8 The 1970s and 1980s 2.8.1 The Environmental Revolution57
2.8.2 The Nixon–Ford Years: 1969–197759
2.8.3 The Carter–Andrus Years: 1977–198159
2.8.4 Reagan Administration: 1981–198960
2.9 Back to the Present65
Why History Is Important for Environmental Decision Making Today and Tomorrow67
3.1 Communications and the Importance of Mediators 3.1.1 George Washington as a Mediator68
3.1.2 Abraham Lincoln as a Mediator69
3.1.3 Theodore Roosevelt as a Mediator70
3.2 Bad Governance Produces Bad Consequences for Society70
3.3 Environmental and Public Health Management 3.3.1 Pre- revolutionary War Period to the 1830s72
3.3.2 The Laissez-Faire Era73
3.4 People and Milestones in American Environmental History74
3.4.1 The Rise of Civil Engineers and Civil Engineering Management in America79
3.4.2 The Role of Federal Science Agencies Prior to 196984
3.4.3 Science Agencies Before World War II: Professional, Apolitical, but Buffeted by Politics87
The Environmental Revolution of the 1970s and Its Outcomes91
4.1 Problems Prior to the 1970s91
4.1.1 The New Environmental Management System92
4.2 Results of the New System98
4.2.1 Positive Outcomes98
4.2.2 Negative Outcomes and Criticisms99
4.3 Underexamined Problems100
4.3.1 Is Congress an Appropriate Environmental Manager?101
4.3.2 Litigation and Litigiousness105
4.3.3 Economic Effects108
4.3.4 US Industrial and Manufacturing Losses109
4.3.5 The US Environmental Management System: Additional Implications and Comparisons113
4.3.6 Benefit/Cost Analysis115
4.3.7 “Sink or Swim” or “We’re All in This Together”116
4.4 Infrastructure118
Why Do Conflict and Polarization Matter?122
5.1 Changing Energy Policies122
5.2 Good Politics Versus “Inspirational” Politics 5.2.1 Developments in the EU125
5.2.2 US Assets125
5.2.3 US Problems126
5.2.4 Examples of Perspectives of Social Scientists131
5.3 Exploring Methods to Reduce CO131
Emissions131
and Their Effects131
5.3.1 Energy Conservation and Efficiency – Costs and Complexities133
5.3.2 Hydropower135
5.3.3 Wind Power136
5.3.4 Ocean Energy – A Modest but Important Symbolic Regulatory Breakthrough141
5.3.5 Biofuels and Biomass144
5.3.6 Other Renewable Energies and Carbon Capture and Storage146
5.4 Discussion146
5.4.1 Offshore Oil and Gas146
5.5 Summary147
Foreign Experience149
6.1 The European Union and Other Nations Take the Lead149
6.1.1 Lawmaking in EU Nations and in the EU153
6.2 Environmental Policies155
6.2.1 Germany and Austria156
6.2.2 Japan158
6.2.3 Canada158
6.3 Scandinavian Nations: Emergence of Post-environmental Societies159
6.3.1 Mining and Environmental Protection162
6.3.2 Where Are the Regulations?163
6.3.3 Norway’s Offshore Petroleum Industry: A Model for Advanced Technology and Environmental Policy165
6.4 Discussion167
6.4.1 The Small, Homogeneous Society Explanation169
6.5 Alternative Energy in Europe 6.5.1 Wave and Tide Energy169
6.5.2 Biofuels171
Reform Efforts and the Future: Where Do We Go from Here?174
7.1 Introduction174
7.2 Selected Critiques and Problems with the Old Regulatory System178
7.3 Reform Efforts – History 7.3.1 Minor Reforms179
7.3.2 Bubble Policy179
7.3.3 Reagan Counterrevolution180
7.3.4 G.H.W. Bush and the Clean Air Act Amendments181
7.3.5 Clinton–Gore Reinventing Government Program181
7.3.6 The Republican Contract with America (1994)183
7.3.7 Endangered Species Act and NEPA Reform183
7.4 Proposals for Reform183