: Daniel Little
: New Contributions to the Philosophy of History
: Springer-Verlag
: 9789048194100
: 1
: CHF 89.70
:
: Methoden der empirischen und qualitativen Sozialforschung
: English
: 240
: Wasserzeichen/DRM
: PC/MAC/eReader/Tablet
: PDF
Insights developed in the past two decades by philosophers of the social sciences can serve to enrich the challenging intellectual tasks of conceptualizing, investigating, and representing the human past. Likewise, intimate engagement with the writings of historians can deepen philosophers' understanding of the task of knowing the past. This volume brings these perspectives together and considers fundamental questions, such as: What is historical causation? What is a large historical structure? How can we best conceptualize 'mentalities' and 'identities'? What is involved in understanding the subjectivity of historical actors? What is involved in arriving at an economic history of a large region? How are actions and outcomes related? The arguments touch upon a wide range of historical topics -- the Chinese and French Revolutions, the extension of railroads in the nineteenth century, and the development of agriculture in medieval China.
Contents6
1 Introduction: Historys Pathways9
1.1 The Historians Tasks13
1.2 History of the Present14
1.3 Metaphors for History16
2 History and Narrative19
2.1 Philosophy and the Historians19
2.2 What Is History22
2.2.1 Micro, Meso, Macro23
2.2.2 Longue Durée25
2.2.3 Marc Bloch's History27
2.2.4 Comparative History31
2.2.5 New Understandings of China's Cultural Revolution34
2.3 Narratives of History36
2.3.1 Selectivity: China at War39
2.3.2 Narrative and Bias40
2.3.3 History, Memory, and Narrative---Recent China42
2.3.4 Age Cohorts and Historical Experience44
2.3.5 Maps and Narratives45
3 Historical Concepts and Social Ontology48
3.1 Ontology and Explanation48
3.1.1 Things49
3.1.2 Events51
3.2 Concepts and Kinds53
3.2.1 Historical Ontology of the French Revolution54
3.2.2 A Tabulation of Historical Ontology59
3.2.3 Do Historical Categories Capture Social Kinds?59
3.3 Methodological Localism64
3.4 The Heterogeneous Social69
3.4.1 Variation71
3.4.2 The Heterogeneous Social Whole73
3.4.3 What Cities Have in Common76
3.5 Conclusions78
4 Large Structures80
4.1 Is France a Nation83
4.2 A Modern World System85
4.3 Revolutions of 184888
4.4 Explaining Fascism90
4.5 Generalizations92
4.5.1 Similarity and Difference94
4.6 Predictions96
4.7 The New Meso-History99
5 Causal Mechanisms103
5.1 A Range of Causal Questions104
5.2 Causal Realism107
5.3 Examples of Social Mechanisms113
5.3.1 Transportation as a Large-Scale Historical Factor114
5.4 Many Small Causes118
5.4.1 Causes of the Chinese Revolution119
5.5 General and Specific Causal Hypotheses123
5.6 Causal Reasoning in Meso-History125
6 History of Technology127
6.1 History of Electric Power128
6.2 Alternative Forms of Industrial Organization131
6.3 Railroads as a Historical Cause133
6.4 Water Transport in China137
6.5 Agriculture and the Natural Environment138
6.6 Warfare: The Franco-Prussian War139
6.7 Technology and Culture142
6.8 Observations from the Examples144
7 Economic History147
7.1 What Is Economic History147
7.1.1 Explanation in Economic History149
7.1.2 Problems of Evidence152
7.2 Aspects of Chinas Rural Economy153
7.2.1 Agricultural History154
7.2.2 Assessment of Available Sources of Data157
7.3 Population History159
7.3.1 The Eurasia Project on Population and Family History161
7.4 Comparative Economic History165
7.4.1 Scale and Scope of Comparison167
7.4.2 Alternative Pathways of Development in Europe and Asia168
7.4.3 Agricultural Revolution and Stagnation Within Europe170
7.5 Contingency and Alternative Pathways of Development174
8 The Involution Debate177
8.1 Chinas Early Modern Rural Economy177
8.2 Involution or Revolution in the Early Qing179
8.2.1 Population Trends182
8.2.2 Productivity182
8.2.3 Real Wage Comparisons184
8.2.4 Institutional Settings184
8.2.5 Environmental Exhaustion185
8.2.6 Conclusions on the Involution Debate187
8.3 Immiseration or Gradual Improvement in Republican China188
8.3.1 The Received View189
8.3.2 Revision190
8.3.3 Price Integration192
8.3.4 Output192
8.3.5 Real Wages193
8.3.6 Productivity195
8.3.7 Distributive Consequences196
8.3.8 Conclusion on Brandt197
8.4 A Puzzle197
8.5 Import for Chinese Studies198
9 Mentalits201
9.1 Mentalits in Historical Inquiry202
9.2 Components of a Mentalit204
9.2.1 Interpretation of Historical Actors and Behaviors205
9.2.2 Darnton, The Great Cat Massacre209
9.3 How Is a Social Identity Created and Reproduced211
9.3.1 E. P. Thompson, The Making of the English Working Class214
9.4 Are Mentalits Stable Over Time217
9.5 Are Mentalits Historical Causes219
9.5.1 Charles Tilly and Contentious Politics220
9.6 Assessment221
Conclusion223
References227
Index239